Comments on: Dissecting Modi’s Farm Bills

By: Mises India

Mises India — Fri, 02 Apr 2021 06:03:11 +0000

In reply to Deepak joshi. Do you have anything substantial to say? Entire Western world has gone mad. Does that mean we go mad? And What is this fascination with the Western world in New India which wants to feel proud of its own ancient traditions?

By: Swami Samarth

Swami Samarth — Thu, 01 Apr 2021 10:44:09 +0000

In reply to Aditya Sangore. You see evil corporates in farm market but there are no evil corporates in other sectors? We took advantage of reforms in other sectors , ending license raj in 1991 but now all of a sudden farm reforms are bad? We have too many who are short sighted and will see farmers continue to be exploited.

By: Deepak joshi

Deepak joshi — Thu, 01 Apr 2021 07:42:41 +0000

The author is a self proclaimed expert who lives in an ivory tower spouting academic proofs in support of his argument. He seems to be so disconnected from the reality that it is but even funny.
“
end, we all must remember that no positive legislation like these bills can establish any free market regime anywhere in the world. The solution of farmers’ problems is neither in the left wing policies of Congress or AAP nor in the right wing fascist policies of BJP. The solution lies somewhere else beyond the political parties like BJP or Congress or AAP etc. Only when the state, with its all political parties, stops existing, we can taste real freedom. Until then it is just an illusion of freedom.“

This alone should demonstrate how out of touch he is.

The entire western world demonstrates that what we are enacting under this bill is right thing to do. We have been perpetually subjecting the poor from lack of choice and ability to sell outside their geography. Creating generational poverty exploited by middlemen be use farmers are forced to sell to them. Look up how the protesting middlemen from Punjab have been gaming the system and illegally procuring at low prices and reselling at higher prices.

By: Mises India

Mises India — Sun, 14 Feb 2021 03:17:55 +0000

In reply to Thomas joseph. "will there be free trade with legal restriction imposed by govt or without restriction?" Sir, you need to read a lot before you write. Please make your concepts clear first and then we can discuss things in better way. Don't pick up pen before your mind is clear.

By: Thomas joseph

Thomas joseph — Tue, 02 Feb 2021 15:21:35 +0000

In reply to Mises India. Can misesindia point out factually, in which part of bill is the middle men, banned as per the new bill? Do you claim that? And, what is mises India's opinion about, will there be free trade with legal restriction imposed by govt or without restriction?